The PTAB recently granted a Patent Owner's motion to take
additional discovery of Petitioner's expert. In particular, the
PTAB ordered Petitioner's expert to produce documents that
identify materials he reviewed in preparing his declaration. Luraco Health &
Beauty, LLC v. Lexor Mfg., LLC, Case IPR2019-00204, Paper
18 (PTAB June 26, 2019).
In Luraco, Petitioner's expert submitted with his
report a list of materials he reviewed. The list identified patents
and one technical handbook. Even though the central issue in the
IPR related to the design and efficiency of centrifugal pumps, the
identified handbook merely related to electric motors. The Patent
Owner, believing that Petitioner's expert likely reviewed
materials relating to centrifugal pumps, served a document request
seeking all materials relating to the design and efficiency of
centrifugal pumps Petitioner's expert reviewed in preparing his
report. Petitioner objected to producing such discovery.