The USPTO issued guidance on the standard for addressing
indefiniteness in AIA trial proceedings. The PTAB will apply
the Nautilus standard in AIA trial proceedings which is
the same standard used by district courts and the ITC.
As background, the USPTO historically applies the standard
articulated in In re Packard, 751 F.3d 1307 (Fed. Cir.
2014) for assessing indefiniteness in ex parte patent
examination. District courts, on the other hand, assess
indefiniteness under the standard articulated by the Supreme Court
in Nautilus, Inc. v. Biosig Instruments, Inc., 572 U.S.
898 (2014). In 2018, the PTAB changed the claim construction
standard used in AIA trial proceedings from the standard used in
ex parte prosecution (broadest reasonable interpretation)
to the standard applied in district courts and the ITC
(Phillips). In the wake of this change, the PTAB has
noted confusion as to whether indefiniteness in AIA trial
proceedings should be assessed under Nautilus or
Pa