Hyatt v. Hirshfeld: Nos. 2018-2390, 2018-2391,
2018-2392, 2019-1038, 2019-1039, 2019-1049, 2019-1070 (Fed. Cir.
June 1, 2021)
Upon appeal, the Patent Office argued that the district court
was wrong to reject its prosecution-laches rejections because the
patent applicant had engaged in a "pattern of delay in
prosecuting his nearly 400 patent applications from 1969 through
the present day." The Federal Circuit panel provided a
detailed history of the prosecution-laches defense and remanded to
the district court for further consideration.
Prosecution laches is a defense that may render patents
unenforceable when there has been an "unreasonable and
unexplained delay in prosecution that constitutes an egregious
misuse of the statutory patent system under a totality of the
circumstances." The doctrine finds its roots in
the Woodbridge v. United States, 263 U.S. 50 (1923),
opinion where the patent applicant had delayed for 8.5 years
before sending a letter to the Patent