Intellectual property (IP) litigation typically requires review
and production of large volumes of documents and electronically
stored information (ESI). The evolution of ESI has greatly
multiplied the number of documents and the coincident broadening of
the attorney-client, work product, joint defense, and other
privileges has made it much more difficult to identify and remove
all privileged documents from production, even after the
introduction of rules designed to lessen the burden presented by
large ESI reviews (e.g., producing email later in a case and within
a narrower scope).
In addition to the increased volume of ESI, the expansion of
what qualifies as privileged has been partially responsible for
introducing unique challenges in IP cases. In Upjohn v. United
States, 449 U.S. 383 (1980), the Supreme Court rejected the
previous narrower "control group" approach in favor of a
broader approach to protecting privileged communications from
disclosure. Although the