In International Leisure Products Inc. v. Funboy LLC
(No. 17-3982, 2d Cir. Sept. 6, 2018), the Second Circuit affirmed
the dismissal—with prejudice—of a trade dress
action that had been brought to protect bird-shaped pool
floats. Noting that trade dress protection (unlike patent and
copyright protection) is unlimited in time, the court emphasized
that “particular caution” must be exercised in
protecting product designs, and that only “distinctive”
designs—not “an idea, a concept, or a generalized type
of appearance”—deserve protection.
International Leisure Products (“Swimline”) had
filed suit against Funboy to protect the design of its “Giant
Swan” pool floats (one of which is pictured above).
Swimline asserted that its trade dress included these seven
elements: