The plaintiff asserted four sports gambling patents against two
defendants. The Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) instituted
inter partes review proceedings on three of the asserted
patents and defendants moved to dismiss the fourth.
The court treated claim 1 as representative and found that it
comprises the following six steps:
- receiving "state information of
a live event in substantially real time,"
- creating a betting market for
possible future states,
- determining probabilities for each of
those future states,
- receiving bets,
- closing the betting market, and
- resolving bets.
Defendants argued that this is the abstract idea of
"managing a betting market during a live sporting event."
Plaintiff countered that defendants oversimplified the claim and
that, instead, the claim is directed to solving a technical problem
in computer technology. Plaintiff’s argument did not convince
the court.