In Tech. Consumer Prods. v. Lighting Sci. Grp.
Corp., the Federal Circuit ruled that the PTAB incorrectly
upheld part of a Lighting Science Group Corp. ("LSG") LED
patent, finding that the PTAB decision was based on
misinterpretation of the claim language and misunderstanding of
case law.
The PTAB found that a reference cited by IPR petitioner
(Technical Consumer Products, Inc.) did not disclose the claimed
height-to-diameter ratio, concluding instead that two heat
dissipation elements in the reference together mapped to the
claimed "heat sink," and the height-to-diameter ratio was
not anticipated if both elements were considered in the
calculation.
On appeal, the Federal Circuit found the PTAB ruling
contradicted the plain claim language, which only required one
particular heat dissipation element in the calculation. The Court
further found the PTAB's claim construction lacked support in
the specification and the prosecution history. LSG argued that