Court Takes Offense to Tactics Geared to PTAB Alone
Litigants beware; Judge Rodney Gilstrap (E.D. Texas) warned
litigants considered to be using the district court proceedings to
posture positions in co-pending CBM proceedings that '[t]he
Court does not countenance—in fact this Court is offended
by—the strategic use of an Article III Court to gain a
tactical advantage in any parallel proceeding."
But, this dispute may be a preview of things to come as the
Patent Trial & Appeal Board (PTAB) aligns itself with the
Phillips construction of the courts.
In United Services Automobile Association v. Wells Fargo
Bank, N.A., 2:18-CV-00245-JRG (E.D. Tex.), USAA brought a suit
for patent infringement against Wells Fargo concerning four patents
directed to remote check deposit technology. On September 18th of
this year, Defendants filed a rule 12(c) motion for judgment on the
pleadings on Section 101 grounds; Plaintiffs filed a response to
the motion on October 26th.