NAD recently reiterated that a claim is a claim and even if
registered and promoted as a trademark still must be supported by
adequate substantiation. In this case Reckitt Benkiser, maker of
dishwasher rinse Finish, challenged claims made by Envirocon
Technologies competing Lemi Shine product. Lemi Shine had
trademarked its catch phrase "Outshines the
Competition." The label also promised that the product
"removes all your hard water spots, stains and residue"
and that "'It's the only thing that works'"
(in quotes) with a disclaimer that the claim was based on daily
consumer feedback.
NAD determined there was a lot of claim cleaning up they had to
do. NAD began by finding that the statement "only thing
that works" was not a puff but a direct comparative
performance claim that required proof. This phrase was
interpreted in connection with the promise that the product removes
the toughest spots. Further, even if consumers would
understand the quotes used to