Can Internet links ever be unlawful? It is a question that has
been asked before, but the answer that's developed through
almost 20 years of extensive public Internet use is this: Mere
reference use of a hyperlink is rarely unlawful. And a recent
federal case from New York, Pearson Education v. Ishayev,
affirmed that conclusion, holding that even a hyperlink to
copyright-infringing materials did not itself constitute
infringement.
The case involved a scheme in which buyers were sold copies of
instructors' manuals for textbooks, and were supplied with
unauthorized, clearly infringing copies of the books. The scheme
was indefensible. And for most of the transactions, where buyers
were sent zip files containing unauthorized copies of the books,
liability was clear at the pre-trial summary judgment stage. After
all, sending a zip file without authorization from the copyright
owner is a reproduction and a distribution of the work — two
of a copyright owner's exclusive