On June 26, 2020, the Federal Circuit issued an opinion
affirming a final written decision of the Patent Trial and Appeal
Board (PTAB) that found certain claims of B/E Aerospace, Inc.'s
aircraft lavatory-related patents obvious. B/E Aerospace, Inc.
v. C&D Zodiac, Inc. (2019-1935, 2019-1936; Slip Op.)
The challenged patents related to space-saving technologies for
aircraft enclosures such as lavatory enclosures, closets, and
galleys. The patents were directed to space-saving modifications to
the walls of aircraft enclosures; they were not directed to the
structures contained within those walls. (Slip Op. at 2.)
The relevant claim limitations at issue on appeal recited a
"first recess configured to receive at least a portion of the
upwardly and aftwardly incline seat back of the passenger
seat," and a "second recess configured to receive at
least a portion of the aft extending seat support therein." In
other words, an upper recess to receive the inclined seat-back,