In a recent decision, the Court of Appeals for the Federal
Circuit held that color marks can be inherently distinctive when
used on product packaging. On April 8, 2020, the Federal
Circuit issued its opinion in In re: Forney Industries,
Inc., vacating a refusal by the Trademark Trial and
Appeal Board ("TTAB") to register a black, yellow,
and red color mark applied to product packaging. In doing so,
the Federal Circuit clarified prior Supreme Court precedent
regarding colors and trade dress, and promulgated a new rule for
analyzing color marks used for product packaging.
A. Background
Forney Industries, Inc. ("Forney"), a metalworking
company that sells accessories and tools for welding and machining,
applied to register the mark below for packaging for various
welding and machining goods.