As patent practitioners are well aware, U.S. patent examiners
will issue a first action on the merits of a patent application as
non-final and typically issue a second action on the merits as
final. The finality of second actions is so universal that the
finality of an action may be accepted as proper by a patent
applicant when, in fact, the action was improperly deemed final. It
therefore behooves applicants to always evaluate whether a final
action on the merits was properly made final to have improper final
actions withdrawn before the applicant incurs unnecessary costs
and/or delays in prosecution.
Section 706 of the Manual of Patent
Examining Procedure (MPEP) outlines the handling of final actions
by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO). Under general
USPTO practice, second or subsequent actions on the merits can be
made final. Additionally, first actions on the merits after the
filing of a Request for Continued Examination (RCE) can be made
final. These