Now more than ever, care should be taken when drafting patent
applications to avoid unintentionally narrowing the claims under
the doctrine of claim scope disavowal.
The
general rule in claim construction is that the words of a claim are
given their ordinary and customary meaning. The doctrine of claim
scope disavowal is an important exception to this general rule and
arises when the patentee disavows the full scope of a claim term,
either in the specification or during prosecution.
Specification-based disavowal can occur in many ways, as
highlighted by recent Federal Circuit decisions. For example, in
May of this year the Federal Circuit issued the Chicago Board decision, reaffirming
the notion that disparaging prior art or alternative embodiments in
the specification can give rise to a disavowal. The Chicago
Board court stated that "[t]he specification goes well
beyond expressing the patentee's preference for a fully
automated exchange over a manual or a