Addressing a question of first impression, the District Court
for the Eastern District of Texas recently held that the defense of
absolute intervening rights applies equally to both product and
method claims in a reissue patent. In doing so, the District Court
granted the defendant's motion for summary judgement of no
pre-reissue damages for products made using the claimed method
prior to issuance of the patent.
Plaintiff Vocalife LLC ("Vocalife") sued defendants
Amazon.com, Inc. and Amazon.com, LLC (collectively,
"Amazon") for infringement of United States Patent No.
RE47,049 (the "'049 Patent"). During the prosecution
of the reissue application which resulted in the '049 Patent,
Vocalife amended two of the asserted independent claims to include
the following limitation: "wherein said sound source
localization unit, said adaptive beamforming unit, and said noise
reduction unit are integrated in a digital processor" (the
"DSP Limitation"). The DSP Limitation was not