CUPP Computing AS ("CUPP") appeals three inter partes
review ("IPR") decisions of the Patent Trial and Appeal
Board ("Board") concluding that petitioner Trend Micro
Inc. had shown challenged claims in CUPP's U.S. Patents Nos.
8,631,488 ("'488 patent"), 9,106,683 ("'683
patent"), and 9,843,595 ("'595 patent")
unpatentable as obvious over two prior art references: U.S. Patent
No. 7,818,803 ("Gordon") and U.S. Patent App. Pub. No.
2010/0218012 A1 ("Joseph").
The three patents at issue address the problem of malicious
attacks aimed at mobile devices. They generally concern systems and
methods for waking a mobile device from a power-saving mode and
then performing security operations on the device. The key issue is
a claim construction that applies to each of the three patents. In
March 2019, Trend Micro petitioned the Board for inter partes
review of several claims in the '488, '683, and '595
patents. Trend Micro argued that the claims were unpatentable as
obvious,