In Short
The Situation: In Joined Cases C‑580/23
(Mio) and C‑795/23 (Konektra), the Court of
Justice ("ECJ") confirmed that works of applied art are
protected by copyright on the same terms as all other works:
originality is the sole requirement. The ECJ also clarified how
originality may be proven and recalibrated the infringement
analysis.
The Development: The ECJ aligned broadly with
Advocate General Szpunar's opinion, and confirmed that
originality is the sole criterion for protection of applied art and
rejected any "rule–exception" relationship with
design law. It rejected additional national thresholds for applied
art, emphasized that the author's intentions are relevant only
insofar as expressed in the work, and held that infringement turns
on recognizable reproduction of the work's original, creative
choices.