Plaintiff Zyrcuits IP LLC has sued Defendants Acuity Brands,
Inc. and Universal Electronics Inc. for infringement of claim 4 of
U.S. Patent No. 6,671,307 (the ‘307 patent). Defendants
argued that Zyrcuits's complaints should be dismissed because
the ‘307 patent is invalid under 35 U.S.C. § 101 for
failing to claim patentable subject matter. Applying the two-step
framework from Alice, the court found that the
‘307 patent was invalid under § 101, as the claims of
the ‘307 patent are directed to the abstract idea of grouping
data together with a single code and do not contain any inventive
concept.
The ‘307 patent describes applying signal codes to blocks
of interleaved data for spread-spectrum transmission. According to
the written description, spread-spectrum transmission was
previously accomplished using parallel codes. Zyrcuits alleged that
Acuity and Universal Electronics infringe claim 4 of the ‘307
patent.