The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit opinion issued
on November 1, 2018 clarifies the standard for a document to
qualify as a "printed publication" under pre-AIA 35
U.S.C. §102(b) and reversed an earlier Patent Trial and Appeal
Board ("PTAB") decision.1 Specifically, the
requirement that a reference be "publicly available" is
not as narrow as the PTAB had interpreted. The Court held that
"the standard for public accessibility [of an alleged prior
art reference] is one of reasonable diligence, to locate the
information by interested members of the relevant public."
The petitioner at the PTAB, GoPro, appealed two final written
decisions by the PTAB which ruled that GoPro failed to provide
evidence that a GoPro catalog qualified as a printed publication
under pre-AIA §102(b). This catalog was GoPro's primary
invalidity reference in the underlying inter partes review
proceedings. To meet its burden as petitioner, GoPro relied on an
unrebutted declaration of