Originally published in PropertyCasualty360 (July 16,
2014)
It is axiomatic that traditional insurance policies cannot be
purchased to cover losses known to exist. A classic example is the
homeowner standing in his basement, with water up to his ankles,
who tries to order flood insurance for the first time.
Insurance companies attempt to expand this general rule by
advocating for a "known loss" bar to coverage (the
"Known Loss Doctrine"), asking courts to analyze whether
circumstances known to the policyholder before the policy was sold
portended a future loss and should have been disclosed to the
insurance company. In other words, insurance companies argue,
coverage should be excluded for any subsequent losses somehow
arising from facts the policyholder knew about.