When a policyholder faces litigation from its insurance company
over a claim submitted by the policyholder, the policyholder often
will defend by alleging that the insurance company has breached the
insurance contract and has wrongfully failed to pay the claim.
Sometimes, however, a policyholder will try to blame the insurance
company’s refusal to pay a claim on others. In a recent case,
a policyholder sought to bring a third-party complaint against
several reinsurers, blaming them for the insurance company’s
actions.
In Integrand Assurance Co. v. Puma Energy Caribe,
LLC, No. 19-1195 (FAB), 2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 221766 (D.
P.R. Dec. 27, 2019), an insurance company brought an action against
its insured alleging fraud and misrepresentation in an insurance
claim submitted by the policyholder to the insurance company. The
policyholder counterclaimed for breach of contract and several
other wrongs, but also purported to bring a third-party complaint
against a group of