Earlier this year, we wrote about two cases that considered
whether an assignee of insurance proceeds could maintain a section
75-1.1 claim against insurers. The North Carolina Business
Court found that such an assignee could maintain the claim
in Brakebush
Brothers. The Fourth Circuit reached the
opposite conclusion in Skyline
Restoration.
Since our post, the Brakebush Brothers court
has revisited the issue. Its new opinion is significant.
No Spring Chicken—The History of Brakebush Brothers
As a reminder, Brakebush Brothers involved a
fire at a chicken-processing plant that resulted in tens of
millions of dollars in damage; that is, more than just chicken
feed. Coincidentally, the fire occurred while the plant was
being sold by House of Raeford Farms to Brakebush Brothers.
Under these circumstances, Raeford Farms tried to assign its rights
to the insurance proceeds to Brakebush Brothers. Some
insurers consented to this assignment. Others did not.