On March 24th, the Supreme Court heard oral argument on the
consolidated appeals of two decisions from the Eleventh Circuit
Court of Appeals, Bank of America v. Caulkett1
and Bank of America v. Toledo-Cardona.2 The
appeals address an issue left unresolved by the Supreme Court's
decision in Dewsnup v. Timm:3 that is, does
section 506 of the Bankruptcy Code void, i.e., "strip
off" a valid junior mortgage lien in a chapter 7 case if the
mortgage loan is completely underwater. These cases involve the
treatment in chapter 7 bankruptcy cases of "undersecured"
or "underwater" second-lien home mortgages. Debtors who
have granted such mortgages have no equity in their houses because
the houses are worth less than the amount outstanding on the
mortgage loans. Generally, there are two types of junior mortgage
liens: closed-end lump-sum mortgage loans, and openend home equity
lines of credit ("HELOCs"). Both of these cases involve
closed-end, lump-sum mortgage loans, but the