Yesterday, the Supreme Court issued a long-awaited ruling in
Executive Benefits Ins. Agency v. Arkison, 573 U.S. __
(2014) (sometimes called "Bellingham" for the name of the
debtor in the main bankruptcy case). A .pdf of the slip opinion
can be found here.
Bellingham is a follow-up to its decision in Stern v.
Marshall, 546 U.S __ (2011), in which the Supreme Court held
that Article III of the United States Constitution prohibits
Article I Courts from exercising the "judicial power of the
United States" to finally adjudicate certain kinds of claims,
even if those claims were expressly categorized as "core"
proceedings in 28 U.S.C. 157(b)(2).
Bellingham settled a circuit split over the division of labor
between Bankruptcy Courts and District Courts when dealing with
"Stern-claims," which SCOTUS defines as claims
that are statutorily-designated as "core," but which
designation is unconstitutional under Stern. The issue is
this: if Stern says a Bankruptcy Court