In Short
The Situation: Since the Supreme Court decided
Morrison v. National Australia Bank Ltd.
("Morrison") in 2010 and rejected the Second
Circuit's "conduct and effects test," the Second
Circuit has grappled with the issue of whether securities and
commodities transactions are sufficiently "domestic" for
the federal securities and commodities laws to apply.
The Result: On August 29, 2019, the Second
Circuit concluded in Prime International Trading, Ltd. v. BP
P.L.C. ("Brent Crude") that the Commodity
Exchange Act ("CEA") could not be applied to certain
derivatives transactions on the New York Mercantile Exchange
("NYMEX") because all of the allegedly manipulative
conduct in the underlying spot market occurred abroad.