When a petitioner offers a will for probate, and the propounded
instrument's validity is contested, objectants oftentimes raise
undue influence as an objection to the admission of the will to
probate. By alleging undue influence, an objectant essentially
contends that the propounded will resulted from another
person's influence on the testator, and, therefore, reflects
the wishes of the alleged undue influencer, rather than the
testator. In this blog post, I write to explain the substantive and
procedural considerations that are relevant to an undue influence
objection in a probate contest.
Undue influence has been described as "a moral coercion,
which restrained independent action and destroyed free agency, or
which, by importunity which could not be resisted, constrained the
testator to do that which was against his [or her] free will and
desire, but which he [or she] was unable to refuse or too weak to
resist" (Children's Aid Soc'y v Loveridge,
70 NY 387, 394