Two months ago, the US Supreme Court heard oral arguments in
Atlantic Richfield Co. v. Gregory Christian. The case is
critically important to environmental lawyers in the United States
because it may alter the operation of Congress's Comprehensive
Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act of 1980
(CERCLA) scheme for environmental remediation. CERCLA gives EPA
broad power to command government agencies and private parties to
clean up hazardous waste sites. In Christian, the Court
will address whether and to what extent private landowners (and
ultimately a jury of lay citizens) can, through state-law
property-rights' claims, contradict EPA's plan for cleanup
and remedial efforts. The outcome of the case implicates the remedy
selection process, millions of dollars in remediation costs,
possibly expands liability for companies dealing with Superfund
Sites, could up-end CERCLA's release and contribution
protection provisions, and portends a possible dramatic