Last month, Judge Robert Wilkins dismissed the federal public
trust climate change law suit, Alec L. v. Jackson. Judge Wilkins
ruled on two alternative grounds. First, he held that there
was no federal public trust doctrine. Second, he held that,
even if there ever had been, such public trust doctrine had been
displaced by the federal Clean Air Act.
However, according to E&E News, Judge Sarah Singleton has just
denied a motion to dismiss a public trust law suit brought in New
Mexico state court under New Mexico law, in Sanders-Reed v.
Martinez. E&E News did not link to any written
decision.
Obviously, the first ground for dismissal in Alec L. v.
Jackson is not relevant to Sanders-Reed. Indeed, Alec
L. v. Jackson makes clear that the public trust doctrine is a
creature of state law, so New Mexico law should be available for
suits to protect New Mexico public trust assets.