When EPA approved total maximum daily loads for the Charles
River, but failed to require NPDES permits for persons discharging
stormwater to the Charles, CLF sued. CLF alleged that EPA
violated a non-discretionary duty when it failed to require the
permits. Last Friday,
Judge Richard Stearns dismissed CLF's suit.
EPA's regulations provide that it will issue NPDES permits
where it:
Determines that the discharge, or category of discharges within
a geographic area, contributes to a violation of a water quality
standard or is a significant contributor of pollutants to waters of
the United States.
CLF argued the nature of the TMDL process means that, in
approving the TMDLs, EPA necessarily made a determination that
certain stormwater discharges were contributing to violations of
water quality standards and thus that permits were required.
EPA took the position that its regulations require a separate and
explicit determination that any particular source or