Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 24 FEBRUARY 2015

Is It Too Late To Just Throw Superfund To The Curb?

The decision is the latest judicial effort to clarify the distinction between cost recovery actions under § 107 of CERCLA and contribution actions under § 113 of CERCLA.

United StatesEnvironment

Last week, Judge Paul Borman of the Eastern District of Michigan, allowed a motion by the United States for judgment on the pleadings, dismissing a third-party complaint brought against the United States by Michigan Consolidated Gas. The decision is the latest judicial effort to clarify the distinction between cost recovery actions under § 107 of CERCLA and contribution actions under § 113 of CERCLA.

I don't have any criticism of Judge Borman's decision. It seems fairly clearly correct under 6th Circuit jurisprudence. I will say, nonetheless, that the decision is gibberish. That's a technical legal term. It's also the reason for this post. Again, I don't criticize Judge Borman. I'm generally opposed to specialist courts. However, does any experienced Superfund practitioner think that a decision such as this will make any sense to a lay person? Isn't that problematic? Here's my ultimate conclusion:

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from