Last week, Judge Paul Borman of the Eastern District of
Michigan,
allowed a motion by the United States for judgment on the
pleadings, dismissing a third-party complaint brought against the
United States by Michigan Consolidated Gas. The decision is the
latest judicial effort to clarify the distinction between cost
recovery actions under § 107 of CERCLA and contribution
actions under § 113 of CERCLA.
I don't have any criticism of Judge Borman's decision.
It seems fairly clearly correct under 6th Circuit
jurisprudence. I will say, nonetheless, that the decision is
gibberish. That's a technical legal term. It's also the
reason for this post. Again, I don't criticize Judge Borman.
I'm generally opposed to specialist courts. However, does any
experienced Superfund practitioner think that a decision such as
this will make any sense to a lay person? Isn't that
problematic? Here's my ultimate conclusion: