Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 07 NOVEMBER 2012

How Much Uncertainty Does CEQA Allow? Court Upholds EIR's Practical Approach For Evaluating Uncertain Cumulative Impacts, But Invalidates Biological Mitigation And Water Supply Analysis As Too Uncertain

In Preserve Wild Santee v. City of Santee, the court immersed itself in an EIR’s evaluation of the impacts of a large residential project proposing 1,395 homes and 1,400 acres of open space preserve.

United StatesEnvironment

In Preserve Wild Santee v. City of Santee, the court immersed itself in an EIR's evaluation of the impacts of a large residential project proposing 1,395 homes and 1,400 acres of open space preserve. The court upheld the analysis of cumulative impacts to biological resources despite the uncertainty regarding the extent of those impacts, but struck down project-level mitigation and an analysis of water supply impacts as too uncertain.

The City's Practical Approach for Addressing Unknown Cumulative Impacts Was Adequate.The EIR acknowledged that because proposed development in the surrounding area was in the early planning stages, the cumulative biological impacts were unknown.  But it explained that the area is covered by a multi-jurisdiction Multiple Species Conservation Program that is designed to protect natural habitats.  Neighboring jurisdictions had adopted subarea plans to implement the Conservation Program, but Santee had completed only a draft subarea plan. 

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from