Last Thursday, in response to a court order, EPA finally proposed revisions to the national ambient air
quality standard for PM2.5. The most significant
part of the rule is EPA's proposal to lower the primary annual
standard from 15 ug/m3 to a range of from 12
ug/m3 to 13 ug/m3.
At a certain level, the proposal should not really be news and
should not have a significant impact. After all, in 2009, the
D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected
EPA's proposal at that time to retain the 15 ug/m3
standard. The court concluded that EPA had not justified
retaining the standard, particularly in light of the recommendation
of EPA's Clean Air Science Advisory Committee to lower the
standard to a range of 12 ug/m3 to 14
ug/m3. Since then, the evidence supporting a lower
standard has only grown stronger. Thus, EPA does not really
have a choice. At some point, the court would get tired of
remanding it to EPA and might instead simply impose a standard.