Those seeking to address climate change through litigation have
taken two different paths. Some cases, probably best represented by
Juliana v. United States, have
plaintiffs who are swinging for the fences. These are stereotypical
examples of impact litigation; the plaintiffs are hoping to
change the world. Other cases involve plaintiffs who are just
hoping – for now, at least – to hit a few singles.
Representative examples include cases brought by the Conservation
Law Foundation against terminals in Massachusetts and Rhode Island,
where CLF claims that the defendants are violating various federal
laws by their failure to prepare for the impact of climate
change.
Two recent stories reaffirmed my believe that, at least for the
near term, the singles hitters are likely to do better than the
home run hitters. First, the home run hitters. Last week, Judge Michael McShane dismissed a case brought
by the Animal Legal Defense Fund in which the plaintiffs asked the
Court to