The Clean Water Act does not cover groundwater. But what if an
aquifer acts as a "conduit" to surface water? Is a
facility liable if pollutants discharged into groundwater
eventually flow into "waters of the United States," which
are covered under the act? Must facilities obtain permits in such
circumstances?
The answer to these questions has been about as clear as mud.
Practitioners are watching to see if the Supreme Court will take up
the issue this term, to resolve a brewing circuit split, and if EPA
and the Justice Department will finally clarify where the
government stands.
The courts have been all over the map. For example, a recent
Ninth Circuit case, County of Maui v. Hawaii Wildlife
Fund, involved a locality-operated wastewater facility that
used underground injection wells to dispose of treated sewage,
where pollutants from the well seeped into the Pacific Ocean
through groundwater. The court held that a National Pollutant
Discharge Elimination System