The Third Circuit Court of Appeals recently upheld the dismissal
of a lawsuit filed by a former bus driver who alleged that he was
fired after his employer refused his request for a religious
accommodation so that he could take Sundays off. The plaintiff
worked for New Jersey Transit ("NJ Transit") as a
part-time bus driver. During his employment, the plaintiff was a
member of a union that was party to a collective bargaining
agreement ("CBA") with NJ Transit. The CBA contained a
provision whereby bus drivers choose their work schedules based on
seniority.
In December 2007, NJ Transit offered the plaintiff a full-time
driver position. During his first month as a full-time driver, the
plaintiff was able to schedule Sundays off so that he could observe
his Sunday Sabbath. In February, however, another full-time driver
with higher seniority returned to work, which left the plaintiff
unable to schedule Sundays off. The plaintiff missed work on two
consecutive Sundays. NJ