Expert's Report Didn't Adequately Explain
Causation
While antitrust cases are often good candidates for class action
treatment, it is still important for the plaintiffs to demonstrate
a connection between the alleged anti-competitive conduct and the
alleged harm, as a recent case from the Western District of Texas
found. In Maderazo v. VHS San Antonio Partners,
L.P., Case No. SA-06-CA-535-OG (W.D. Tex. Jan. 22, 2019),
the plaintiffs were registered nurses working for hospitals in the
San Antonio area. They contended that between 2002 and 2007, the
hospitals conspired to hold down the wages paid to their nursing
staffs. This was accomplished, they contended, through a
combination of participation in salary surveys and in-person, email
and telephone communications between human resources employees of
different hospitals. The proposed class had between roughly 5,000
and 11,000 members. Following what appears from the docket to have
been nearly 10 years of litigation,