I can imagine many Americans reading this headline and getting
angry, "Chicago Woman Fired for Doing Work at Lunch Wins
Unemployment Claim." But in the words of a childhood favorite
of mine, it is important to know "the rest of the
story."
Sharon Smiley, a ten year tenured receptionist for a Chicago real
estate company, was fired for working through lunch. Yes, you read
that correctly, she was fired for working through
lunch.1 Company policy at her employer, Equity Lifestyle
Properties, Inc., required all hourly, nonexempt employees to take
a 30 minute lunch break. However, on January 28, 2010, Ms. Smiley
clocked out for lunch, but returned to her desk at the front of the
office and began working on a spreadsheet on her computer,
answering the phone and responding to questions for those who
approached her desk (the sort of things she did as part of her
regular job duties). A manager saw what she was doing and told her
to step away from her desk and go to lunch. Ms.