Under what is called the "functional equivalent"
doctrine, courts sometimes treat independent contractors as if they
are corporate employees when analyzing privilege protection. Most
courts examine criteria such as the independent contractors'
physical presence at the client's offices, etc. Courts taking
an expansive view of the doctrine bump into the traditional
principle that the only client agents/consultants within the
privilege are those necessary for the transmission of
communications with the client's lawyer.
In In re Flonase Antitrust Litigation, Civ. A. Nos.
08-CV-3149 & -3301, 2012 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 91155 (E.D. Pa. July
2, 2012), the Eastern District of Pennsylvania found that employees
of a "national consulting firm that provides pharmaceutical
consulting services" should be considered the "functional
equivalent" of GlaxoSmithKline employees. Id. at *7.
The court rejected what it called a "narrow construction"
of the functional equivalent doctrine, finding