Among the many purposes underlying Congress' enactment of
the Employee Retirement Income Security Act ("ERISA") was
giving employers flexibility in plan design.1 This
discretion should encourage employers to offer benefits by giving
them the ability to decide which benefits to offer and, relatedly,
the ability to control the costs and administrative burdens they
are willing to assume.2
In a related vein, the Federal Arbitration Act's3
"liberal federal policy favoring arbitration agreements"
can provide employees and employers "quicker, more informal,
and often cheaper resolutions" of workplace-related
disputes.4
These two statutes appear to present complementary frameworks.
Therefore, one might think the ability of employers to require
arbitration of disputes arising under ERISA would be a
straightforward proposition. However, as with so many other legal
principles, there may be competing considerations that call into
question even a seemingly simple premise.