Nathan A Adams IV is a Partner in Holland &
Knight's
Tallahassee office.
In Mielo v. Steak 'N Shake Operations, Inc., 897 F.
3d 467 (3d Cir. 2018), the court of appeals ruled that disability
rights advocates who brought a putative class action against an
operator of a restaurant chain under the ADA satisfied the injury
in fact, traceability and redressability test for Article III
standing, but not the numerosity or commonality test for class
certification. The plaintiffs alleged that they personally
experienced difficulty ambulating in their wheelchairs through two
steeply graded parking facilities at two restaurant locations. For
numerosity, the plaintiffs pointed to the large number of
handicapped persons in the U.S. but failed to present evidence on
how many handicapped persons patronized the restaurant locations,
let alone experienced ADA violations. The court was also not
impressed that a single executive of the defendant speculated that
thousands of disabled