Today, we're reviewing the pattern of Justice Karmeier's
questions in oral argument on criminal cases.
When Justice Karmeier joins the majority of a simple affirmance
or reversal, his questions show the expected pattern – he
tends to more heavily question the losing side. In affirmances, he
averages 1.88 questions to appellants and 0.68 to appellees. In
reversals, he averages 1.82 to appellees and 1.36 to appellants. In
the slightly less clear case of when Justice Karmeier joins a split
decision – affirmed in part, reversed in part – he
averages 1.98 questions to appellees and 1 to appellants.
When Justice Karmeier is in the dissent in a criminal case, he
tends to more heavily question the party he thinks should lose
rather than the party which will lose. When the majority affirms
and he votes to reverse, he averages 1.8 questions to appellees and
0.8 to appellants. When the majority reverses and he votes to
affirm, he averages 2.29 to appellants and 0.57 to