How do jurors reach their verdicts? It's simple: they vote
for the party whose witnesses they like best.
Early in my career, I handled a criminal defense matter. The
client had been charged with burglarizing a home in an affluent
Philadelphia suburb. Among the stolen items was a credit card that
had been used shortly after the burglary to buy a set of tires at a
nearby gas station. The Philadelphia Police Department's chief
handwriting expert analyzed the forged signature on the credit card
receipt and concluded that it matched a sample of my client's
handwriting.
The defense? My client claimed that on the afternoon of the
burglary he had been fishing alone far from the crime scene. He had
no corroboration for his story. My client was from South Philly
with a spotty work history who couldn't have been less like the
suburban jurors if the prosecution had hand-picked him. My client
insisted on his innocence, so we went to trial.