In United States ex rel. Holmes v. Northrop Grumman Corp., No.
1:13-cv-85, 2015 WL 3504525 (S.D. Miss. June 3, 2015), the court
answered this question with a resounding "no" and
provided a laundry list of ethical violations that the attorney
Relator had violated in attempting to advance his qui tam
action. The Holmes court's holding serves as a staunch
reminder to attorneys that their ethical obligations are paramount
and reinforces the notion that courts throughout the nation do not
look favorably upon opportunistic relators who rely on improper
means to gain access to documents to support their FCA claims.
In 2005, Hurricane Katrina severely damaged several ships that
Defendant had been contracted to construct for the United States
Navy. As a result of the damage, Defendant filed a claim with
its insurer, Munich Re, who in turn was represented by
Holmes—the Relator in the instant dispute. During the
course of the adjustment process, Defendant and Munich Re