No doubt, ensuring that any agreement is consistent with
judicial precedent is critical if you want to enforce that
agreement at some point in the future. Nevertheless, merely
incorporating precedential concepts or language into an agreement
may not be enough to get your client to where it wants to be, and
may even result in your client being put in a more difficult
position than if the precedent had been ignored. Nowhere is this
more apparent than when a company seeks to draft and implement a
standard and seemingly straightforward noncompete covenant.
In Kroger v. The Stop & Shop Companies,
Inc., Stop & Shop sought to enforce a covenant not to
compete against Mr. Kroger that expressly precluded him from
working for any other supermarket east of the Mississippi River
– unless it was in Florida, Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi or
Louisiana. At the time this case was litigated, however, Stop &
Shop only did business in New England, New York and New Jersey
– and had no