The young IP litigator in the big New York firm licked his chops. One of his firm’s best clients, also a New York-based business, had, as part of its routine market monitoring, noticed an up-tick in knockoffs of a major new product, earmuffs in the shape of the distinctive noggin of a popular cartoon character. The product was protected by a whole suite of intellectual property registrations: A copyright on the character, a pending design patent, and a registered trademark. Together with counsel and local law enforcement, the client had succeeded, in a low-key, low-impact way, in seizing or otherwise cutting off distribution of the infringing merchandise. So far, so good.
But word had leaked back through "channels" that a major out-of-state manufacturer of the infringing goods was angling for a fight. He believed the copyright was lapsed, the design patent would be rejected, the trademark registration was invalid -- something for everything. He stood to make a lot of money on the