Summary
The U.S. Courts of Appeal for the First and Second Circuits have
split on the issue of whether a plaintiff must satisfy the Second
Circuit's “predominantly foreign” test (set forth
in Parkcentral Global Hub Ltd. v. Porsche Automobile
Holdings SE1) to demonstrate that a transaction is
“domestic” under the U.S. Supreme Court's
“domestic transactions in other securities” [second]
prong from Morrison v. National Australia Bank
Ltd.2 — even if this plaintiff has
already satisfied the traditional “irrevocable
liability” test.
Earlier this year on January 25, the Second Circuit
reaffirmed Parkcentral in Cavello Bay
Reinsurance Ltd. v. Shubin Stein3.
In Cavello Bay, the court held that the
“predominantly foreign” test is an additional standard
to be considered when applying Morrison. The decision
broadened Park Central's applicability and
presents an additional hurdle for a plaintiff to overcome in
pleading facts to demonstrate a domestic transaction.