On April 14, the US Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit stuck
down portions of the Security and Exchange Commission's (SEC)
Final Rule on Conflict Minerals (Final Rule) as unconstitutional.
In National Association of Manufacturers v. Securities and
Exchange Commission, the Court held that requiring regulated
entities to report to the SEC and on their website that their
products have "not been found to be 'DRC conflict
free'" violated the First Amendment. The decision raises
important questions as the first reports to publicly disclose use
of "conflict minerals" pursuant to the Final Rule are
coming due on June 2, 2014.1
The ultimate effect of the decision is unclear, however, as the
free speech holding may be affected by an upcoming en banc
decision of the Court in American Meat Institute v. United
States Department of Agriculture (the hearing is scheduled for
May 19, 2014). While it remains to be seen how the SEC will respond
to the Court's decision, with the