This blog's earlier post, "
Protect Your Safety Investigations and Deliberations From Prying
Eyes," highlighted the three privileges that are useful
for Safety Teams – self-critical analysis privilege (or
self-evaluation privilege), attorney-client privilege, and work
product doctrine. These three privileges can help a manufacturer
protect its information regarding product safety analysis when
dealing with product liability litigation. These privileges,
however, are not in any way capable of protecting all of such
information.
The self-critical analysis privilege protects only the results
of candid assessments of the company's compliance with laws and
regulations. There are usually four or five criteria that must be
met before a court accepts this privilege. Furthermore, only a
limited number of jurisdictions have adopted this privilege. It
would be prudent for companies to check whether the likely
jurisdiction of its anticipated litigation adopts this privilege