Large hospitals and health systems have filed a spate of
antitrust suits against various Blue Cross and Blue Shield (BCBS)
carriers, including Elevance Health and Health Care Service Corp.
These plaintiffs in the recent lawsuits are those health system
giants that opted out of the $2.8 billion antitrust settlement that
BCBS agreed to last fall. They had until March 29, 2025, to reject
the settlement and file suit.
The plaintiff health systems, which include Adventist Health,
Bon Secours Mercy Health, CommonSpirit Health, Community Health
Systems, Temple University Health, and the University of
Pennsylvania Health System, allege that BCBS insurers and managed
care companies colluded to limit competition in the health
insurance market. The BCBS Association member companies allegedly
colluded in violation of antitrust laws by forcing them to avoid
operating in other members' home markets or “exclusive
service areas.”