On January 29, 2024, the Delaware Supreme Court decided
Cantor Fitzgerald, L.P. v. Ainslie, a closely-watched case
involving the enforceability of forfeiture-for-competition
provisions in a Delaware limited partnership agreement. The
Delaware high court reversed a decision by the Court of Chancery,
which invalidated the provisions as unreasonable restraints on
trade. The Supreme Court's decision establishes that, absent
exceptional circumstances, Delaware courts will enforce
forfeiture-for-competition provisions as written between
sophisticated parties, without subjecting them to a reasonableness
review. Several other states have reached the opposite conclusion,
and Cantor Fitzgerald reinforces Delaware's reputation
as a contractarian jurisdiction that will hold parties to their
bargain, good or bad. The decision has significant
implications—particularly so for private investment firms,
which are commonly structured as Delaware partnerships like Cantor
Fitzgerald.